When you’ve experienced life in various states and are raising three children as a former educator, discussions about schooling arise quickly when meeting new people. My journey led me to teach in different regions, obtaining licenses in places like Massachusetts, Nebraska, and Wisconsin. While I eventually stepped away from teaching to focus on motherhood, the topic of schools has always remained a priority for me. I’ve toured numerous campuses, engaged with principals, and conducted extensive research to determine the best educational paths for my children.
Throughout my experiences, one constant has been the public school system. I grew up in suburban Connecticut, where my parents chose our home largely due to its proximity to the local public schools. My entire K-12 education occurred within the same district, so pursuing a career in public education felt like a natural progression when I earned my teaching certificate.
Are there public schools in need of improvement? Absolutely. However, the widespread belief that private institutions provide a superior education is misleading.
As a mother of three school-aged children, I’ve become increasingly aware of the stigma surrounding public education—something I hadn’t considered before. This misconception is troubling to me, both as a parent and as someone who has been deeply involved in the public schooling system.
Here’s the reality: every school faces challenges. Every institution has staff members who may not be fully committed, and all schools serve children who come from varied backgrounds with different levels of support at home. Each school operates within a budget, allocating resources for teachers, supplies, and necessary programs.
Both public and private schools have successful students and those who struggle. They have dedicated teachers who inspire and those who may not live up to expectations. Both types of schools also expose children to experiences, some of which parents might not be ready for.
So why do proponents of private schooling often elevate their institutions above public schools? A recent study highlighted by The Washington Post debunks this myth, revealing that private schools do not necessarily provide a better education when socio-demographic factors are considered. Researchers from the University of Virginia analyzed data from over 1,000 students and found that public schools can be just as effective when accounting for family backgrounds.
The current discourse around privatizing public education, championed by figures like Betsy DeVos, is particularly concerning. As a member of one of the wealthiest families in America, DeVos’s perspective may be skewed by her own experiences in private education. Her claim that public schools represent a “dead end” is not only offensive but also dismisses the hard work of countless teachers who dedicate themselves to their students every day.
These educators provide invaluable emotional and academic support, often going above and beyond for their students, all while earning a modest salary. The assumption that public schools are inferior is not backed by evidence; when socioeconomic factors are removed, there are no significant differences in educational quality between public and private institutions.
As a former public school educator and a parent whose children are enrolled in public schools, I take pride in our public education system. It’s important to challenge the narrative perpetuated by individuals like DeVos, who imply that my children and others in public schools are receiving an inadequate education.
In fact, research indicates that the success of students is closely tied to parental education and income rather than the type of school they attend. This pattern holds true for both public and private institutions. For additional insights on this topic, you can check out this blog that discusses educational choices.
While there are certainly public schools that require attention and resources, the notion that private schools inherently provide a superior education is simply untrue. They often cater to affluent students who are already privileged.
In summary, all students deserve access to quality resources, whether they attend public or private schools. Every child should have the necessary support to thrive academically. It’s time for a shift in focus—let’s advocate for improvements across all educational settings, ensuring that every child has the tools they need to succeed.
For further information on fertility journeys, visit Make a Mom, and for comprehensive resources regarding IVF and home insemination, check out NHS.
Leave a Reply