The early days of motherhood can be incredibly draining. Nights are often filled with little sleep, leaving new moms feeling perpetually groggy. During my own journey into motherhood, after nine months of cutting back on caffeine, I often wished for an IV drip to keep me alert. However, as I navigated breastfeeding, I found myself uncertain about the guidelines surrounding caffeine consumption. I was aware that caffeine should be limited during pregnancy, but I had questions about whether the same restrictions applied to breastfeeding. I had heard that caffeine might impact a baby’s sleep, but I wasn’t sure if that was just a myth or a fact. Honestly, I was too exhausted to seek out the answers.
Many new mothers share these same concerns. To shed light on this topic, we consulted with Sarah Thompson, a Certified Lactation Consultant, and Dr. John Michaels, a board-certified OB-GYN with extensive experience, who hosts a podcast on pregnancy and birth.
Babies React to Caffeine Differently
When it comes to infants, there’s no universal rule. What works for one baby may not work for another. The same principle applies to how caffeine affects breastfed babies. Caffeine passes into breast milk, and “some babies may be more sensitive to caffeine, which can lead to fussiness and refusal to nurse,” explains Thompson. She adds that this refusal to nurse can potentially decrease breastfeeding duration and milk supply.
Since caffeine affects different babies in varying degrees, it’s crucial to observe how your intake impacts your little one, keeping an eye out for signs of increased fussiness or wakefulness.
Moderation is Key
For caffeine enthusiasts, the good news is that complete elimination isn’t necessary. Thompson advises that moderate consumption—about one to two caffeinated beverages per day—is generally safe for breastfeeding mothers. “Aim for no more than 100-200mg of caffeine daily, provided your baby tolerates it well,” she notes, mentioning that an 8-ounce cup of coffee typically contains around 100mg of caffeine. This guideline mirrors recommendations for caffeine intake during pregnancy. Dr. Michaels emphasizes that research indicates up to 200mg of caffeine is safe during pregnancy.
It’s important to remember that caffeine is also found in tea, chocolate, soda, and energy drinks, so it’s the total quantity that matters.
Pumped Milk and Caffeine Sensitivity
As a new mom, I had heard that if I consumed caffeine before pumping, I should only use that milk in the morning to avoid keeping my baby awake. However, I often forgot to label my pumped milk, especially during those overwhelming early days.
According to Thompson, this notion isn’t entirely accurate. For sensitive babies, it might be useful to label milk that could contain caffeine. For instance, if you enjoy your morning coffee and your baby is sensitive, it may help to designate that milk for daytime feeding. However, for babies who don’t exhibit sensitivity, this step may not be necessary. “It’s all about experimenting to find what works best for you and your baby,” Thompson advises.
Navigating Judgment About Caffeine Choices
New mothers frequently face unsolicited opinions and judgments from others, and caffeine consumption can be a particularly sensitive subject. Amidst the sleepless nights, the last thing any mother needs is criticism.
Thompson encourages everyone to remember that each mother’s journey is unique. “We all need to reflect on how we feel when our choices are judged and extend that understanding to others,” she advises. For new moms seeking guidance on caffeine or any other parenting choices, resources like The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) can be incredibly helpful.
No two babies or mothers are alike. It’s essential to stay informed and make decisions that suit you and your baby best. For more insights, you can explore this other blog post.
Summary
In summary, caffeine can be safely consumed in moderation while breastfeeding, but its effects can vary among infants. New mothers should monitor their baby’s reactions to caffeine and adjust their intake accordingly. Support and understanding are key, as every mother’s experience is unique. For further information on artificial insemination and related topics, check out this excellent resource. Additionally, for more information about home insemination kits, visit Make a Mom.

Leave a Reply