My Concerns About Cancel Culture — From the Perspective of a Black Woman

Is it just me, or is anyone else tired of the ongoing conversation around cancel culture? I wholeheartedly support addressing issues like racism, sexism, transphobia, and other forms of discrimination. That’s how cancel culture started. Yet, it seems like this important form of social activism has become a political game, and honestly, as a Black woman, I’m fed up with it.

For those who may not be familiar, cancel culture refers to the social exclusion faced by individuals or organizations for actions deemed objectionable or offensive. This often involves boycotting their work, blocking them on social media, or pushing for disciplinary measures from employers or authorities.

Typically, cancel culture arises when a public figure or private citizen is caught making offensive remarks or engaging in unacceptable behavior. This usually sparks a backlash on social media, leading to calls for their cancellation. While there are certainly instances where consequences are warranted, the subjectivity of cancel culture complicates matters. Some view it as censorship, while others believe it democratizes accountability. Personally, I feel it has empowered marginalized voices to hold others accountable for their actions, making it harder for bigotry and discrimination to go unchecked.

There’s nothing quite like a social media outcry to demand accountability. Cancel culture has effectively challenged harmful behaviors and ignited critical discussions, such as #OscarsSoWhite and the revelations of sexual misconduct during the #MeToo movement. The consequences for some individuals, like Kevin Spacey and R. Kelly, have been severe, while others, like JK Rowling and Amy Cooper, faced backlash for their problematic statements and actions.

However, there are cases where cancel culture has gone too far. People have faced backlash for resurfaced tweets from years ago, traveling during a pandemic, or even expressing unpopular opinions. For instance, Alexi McCammond lost her job as editor of Teen Vogue over anti-Asian comments made in high school. Such instances raise questions about the fairness of canceling someone for past mistakes when larger systemic issues, like Vogue’s treatment of Black creatives, remain unaddressed.

Celebrities like the Kardashians and Lizzo have also faced calls for cancellation over various controversies, highlighting the complexity of accountability. While some actions deserve scrutiny, we must allow space for growth and understanding.

When “clicktavists” mobilize against any perceived slight with a mob mentality, it dilutes the significance of cancel culture. This shift has, unfortunately, sparked more anger than meaningful dialogue. Politicians have also appropriated cancel culture for their own agendas, sidestepping the voices of those who are genuinely marginalized.

We must remember that the real issues at stake revolve around the daily struggles faced by individuals combating racism, sexism, and bigotry. It would be more productive if we channeled our energy into advocating for justice and equality within our communities. It’s easier to point fingers than to take responsibility for how marginalized populations are treated in this country.

In case you’re looking for more information on this subject, check out this related blog post on home insemination and find additional resources at Make a Mom and March of Dimes.

Summary

Cancel culture, while initially a means to hold individuals accountable for discriminatory actions, has evolved into a divisive political tool that often undermines its original purpose. The focus should return to meaningful dialogue and advocacy for marginalized communities rather than punitive measures that sometimes miss the mark.