Fans of "You" Speculate on Joe Goldberg's Possible Half-Brother

A captivating fan theory circulating among followers of “You” suggests that Joe Goldberg may share a deeper connection with Theo Engler than mere proximity. As the series’ third season has captivated audiences, this theory could set the stage for an even more thrilling fourth season—and we’re definitely intrigued.

For those who have binged Season 3, beware of spoilers ahead!

Let’s Unpack This Theory

Theo, the 19-year-old next-door neighbor of Joe and Love, is the stepson of Matthew Engler, who is married to Natalie—the woman who caught Joe’s eye at the end of Season 2. One major mystery remains: we never learn the identity of Theo’s biological mother. This has led fans on Reddit to speculate that Theo might actually be Joe’s younger half-brother.

Consider this: in a flashback, Joe sees his mother with a young boy named Jacob after a period in the foster care system. While it’s never confirmed that Jacob is her son, the implication is strong. Fans believe Jacob is actually Theo, suggesting that the charming neighbor could indeed be Joe’s sibling.

What About the Name Discrepancy?

Fans have a theory for that too. For instance, Joe’s son Henry is often referred to by his middle name, “Forty,” a tribute to Love’s deceased twin. Perhaps Theo’s full name is Jacob, and he simply prefers to go by his middle name. “The odds that his brother from New York would end up in the same LA suburbs living next door is soap opera-level nonsense,” joked one Reddit user. Another added, “Unless Love planned this whole house arrangement from the start.”

One fan even explored the meanings behind the names Theo and Jacob, adding layers to this wild theory. One Redditor noted, “Theo” is linked to a French psychologist known for his work on memory, suggesting: “What if the woman Theo believes is his biological mother isn’t actually his mother? Maybe she gave him up at a young age, and he was adopted and renamed Theo!”

Furthermore, the name Jacob means “supplanter” and has biblical ties to a story of twins, which could reflect Joe’s feelings about his younger brother taking what he perceived as his rightful place in the family. With Theo still holding that USB drive over Joe, it’s clear this theory has some serious implications for the future of the series.

We won’t be able to shake this theory off until Season 4 drops!

Search Queries:

In summary, fans are buzzing with a thrilling theory that Joe Goldberg and Theo Engler could be half-brothers, igniting excitement for the upcoming season of “You.” With the connections between their names and backstories, viewers are left to ponder the implications this could have for the characters’ futures.